No, this blog post has nothing to do with the segregation
laws and the Civil Rights movement, although, that is a fascinating time
period. The phrase though, separate but equal, can be used to explain the role
of women in Early Greek History. With the tales of the heroes and the glory of
war, oftentimes we forget to look at what role the women had. Therefore, they
are usually left in the background, yet they are mentioned often enough that
they must have had some role in society.
I mean, let’s take a look at Penelope, Odysseus wife. She must
have been something special and important to Odysseus if he spent ten years
trying to get back to her. When he finally returns to Ithaca, poor Penelope
fearing a trick asks Odysseus a question which would prove his true identity.
She states to the servant, “move the sturdy bedstead out of our bridal chamber –/that
room the master built with own hands.” (the Odyssey,
book 23, lns 198-99) She says this knowing that the true Odysseus would know
that there was no way you could move the bed he built. She shows her wit is comparable to Odysseus’ who is known as being extremely clever (i.e, my name
is Nothing).
Not only do we see that Greek women were comparable in
smarts, we also read of their beauty. I mean, seriously, the Gods oftentimes “fell”
for mortal women that were beautiful, Zeus, God of Gods, probably the most. In
times of war, once one side conquered they would plunder and divide gifts of which
women would be considered a prize with the most beautiful usually going to the
Commander. They were considered great “gifts” as we learn when Achilles’ honor
is wounded when he has to give up his girl (Iliad)
Then of course we learn that even though they were fairly
equal they still carried a very domestic role. The princess of Phaeacia,
Nausicaa, was at the river doing laundry. (Odyssey)
I mean, you have someone that is royalty
that is cleaning clothes. Also, in the Underworld all the women introduced
themselves as “I am…mother of….” The
role of child-bearing and nurturing was also an apparent important role to the
Greeks when it came to women. There were
obvious distinguishing duties of men and women.
I think these roles of Greek women are still very relevant
in society today. Women can be comparable to men intelligence-wise. There are
many women that are equal in the work force and oftentimes even excel. But,
even in the home, many people I know that are dating and then eventually
married usually are with a partner that they are compatible with. Most times
you can just look at them or listen to them and think, “Oh, that’s why you two
are together. You just fit.” Then beauty is still an important cultural item. There is such a push and expectation for women to be beautiful. Thank goodness we are all beautiful in different ways and to different people. Then most important, mothers are still an essential role in today’s society.
Mothers are primarily responsible for the nurture of their children. (The Family: Proclamation to the World) Basically
I think the Greeks weren’t too far off from what we think and see women as
today. We can be considered separate because we have different roles but they
are still equal in importance to men. Besides, we hold our own pretty well I’d say. :)
I feel like you had some really good arguments that I hadn't considered before. I always get caught up on the fact that women were considered prizes or objects, but you are totally right that they were influential enough in their own way to change the world and its fate. Nations went to war, immortals did crazy stupid things, men went crazy, all over women. I still feel like they weren't as equal then as they are today since I think we have a lot more freedom of choice in how we live our lives, but you definitely opened my mind up to just how much influence they were able to exert.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with you that women are capable of doing anything just as good or better than men. I have worked in several industries were women don't have a large presence, but those that were there always excelled at what they did. Also, something interesting we notice about the Greeks view on women can be found in the New Testament. In the book of Luke that was primarily written for a Greek audience there is a lot more mention of women and the important roles they played in society.
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you thought of Penelope's question being a display of her intelligence. I never noticed that before but it is so true that women are just as witty and intelligent as men.
ReplyDeleteIts interesting how you noticed a lot of the same things the Greeks value are the same things we value. Maybe the world doesn't values those same things, but when I say "we" and I think when you see "we" you mean the Mormon church. It is interesting to see how closely related our values are with ancient cultures.
ReplyDelete